THE GAME CUSTOMIZATION NETWORK: FPSB | RTSB | RPGB |
Help Wanted: Modeller @ Invision Arts (See All) | SUBSCRIBE
U: P:

Register or Reset Password
 
Members > TheBishop > Assessments
StatsBuddiesStudiosSkin SubmissionsRanksAssessmentsScript SubmissionsClubsSpray SubmissionsBlogItems For Sale
Add this module
Assessments
Below are the submissions you've assessed and the feedback you provided with your assessment. Your statistics will rebuild daily.
Page of 4   1 2 3 4 Next Page
Submission Assessment
Maps > dod_rainbowisland
I played this on a server yesterday, and while it is a fun map, I do have some gripes.

First off, the spawns are low enough to where I spawn partially clipped in to the floor. Second, the teleporters, while they are a great idea, are a little sluggish in my opinion.

Aside from those two things, it's an over all good job.
The map is very nice looking and aside from the things I mentioned before, fun as well.

Might I suggest different criteria to rate upon next time? Ambience and looks go hand and hand, so do fun and gameplay. Trying to rate this map fairly while not forgetting the complaints feels broken.
Approved
9/10
Skins > A Bloody Redwood Sandman
Originality: I gave you an 8.5 only because there is always a bloody skin. Yours is done nicely, but, it's nothing new or groundbreaking.
Realism: The wood looks very nice, and the improved wrap looks good too. The blood isn't cartoony and the coagulating around the edges looks good too. Not sure if you meant it to be like that, but it's done well.
Texture: The dark wood is nice like I said, and the bandage goes with it perfectly. Well done on the color scheme. The only reason I docked is that in the in-game screen, the sandman logo looks like it has a very jagged black border, as if it wasn't cut out well during the process. If it is really not the case, I will be happy to change this.
Approved
9/10
Scripts > http://www.rpgbanana.com/scripts/3942
Pros: Uh, read the thing! You could potentially have a TON of uber time. Medic tanking for the win. Very quick to boot.
Cons: Maybe a better key than left shift. It's kinda too close. Might be better on something like C...
Improvements: None.
Notes: Glad I could help you with this.
Approved
9.9/10
Skins > 2 Team Coloured Disguise Cases
Pros: Looks good, no visible flaws from screens. Nice sleek dark skin.
Cons: None really. Never seen a blue filter on a smoke before :P
Improvements: Again, none that I can think of.
Notes: Great job, very nice dark skin. I really like this style (dark[er]). Was tempted to take off .5 point on originality since it's nothing new, but I like it, so I didn't. :D

Good job on the 1.9.4 maps as well :)
Approved
10/10
Skins > Bullet Bill Rockets
Pros: Awesome stuff, like always. Lighting is great, as is the shaping of the hands.
Cons: None.
Improvements: Zero.
Notes: Keep up the good work man.
Approved
10/10
Skins > Pikachu Head Stickys
Pros: Good texture, nice renders.
Cons: The head is a bit lopsided and there could be more normal mapping for the bone structure and facial features.
Improvements: Needs to be more detailed as far as mapping.
Notes: Good idea. Some Pokemon themed sticky would go well in a pack.
Approved
8.5/10
Skins > Tranquilizer Gun
This is a great release. The sounds and animations are great. The texture, while not that detailed is not bad or of poor quality. Sure, it could be more "realistic" but that is not what TF2 is about. It's perfectly acceptable.

The low critic rating obviously shows that the system is a bullshit hierarchical one. It ruins the scores of perfectly fine skins and maps and models etc. It needs to be gotten rid of.
Approved
9.6/10
Skins > Clean & brighten Axtinguisher
Pros: It's the first axtinguisher skin! And it's not dirt at that. The brightness is definitely an improvement over the original.
Cons: The map you chose doesn't have good lighting for screens. You really want a crisp light, without the yellow sunset tones like that one. This is crucial if its supposed to be showing off a brightened skin.
Improvements: New screenshots would be nice.
Notes: Good to know I'm not the only one on FPSB who got it the first day. >:3
Approved
9.5/10
Skins > Ravager
Pros: The blood splatter looks very good. It's better than a few I have seen.
Cons: The text. I'm not the biggest fan of words on skins, but it's nothing that would get you points off of an assessment. But the font and text effects do however. It seems like you just put the word in a random spot then added a few cheesy overlays.
Improvements: Redo or take the text off.
Approved
9/10
Skins > Animated Blutsauger
Pros: Awesome. That's all I can think of to say. It's good to see more animated weapons be put out. They make the game that much better.
Cons: The idiots saying, "Oh it's supposed to go down too hurf hurf." They missed the point.
Improvements: A faster animation might look better, but npt sure so no biggie.
Notes: Sick job.
Approved
10/10
Page of 4   1 2 3 4 Next Page
Theme: | 168 Members Online | File Mirrors | Terms of Service | Rules | Advertise here | Contact | Report a problem