RPGBANANA > Members > Siro

Browse

Members > Siro >

StatsSubmissionsPlayerCustomizerClubsRanksAssessmentsProfile Guardian

Search Members: Advanced

Add this module

Assessments

Warning: max() [function.max]: Array must contain at least one element in /home/system/classes/Subsystem/Statistic/Rebuild.class on line 65

Below are the submissions you've assessed and the feedback you provided with your assessment. Your statistics will rebuild daily.

Page of 14 1 2 3 4 ... 12 13 14

	Submission	Assessment
	Maps > aim_devneon Very well done, dude. I can see the effort.	Approved 10/10
	Skins > SPAS 12 retexture This texture looks nice. It's not perfect, though. There could be some colour variation, like on a real one. You should have used some blue-greenish tint on the heat-cover along which the pump moves. The pump could also be more realistic if you took away the indents. Other than that, the metal looks nice and suits the gun, but again, colour variation. Looks slighlty drab.	Approved 9/10
	Skins > AKM retexture The metal on this AK is VERY nicely done. It suits the weapon very well. I think it should be slightly lighter and have more shine on it, unless you want to make it matte like on modern AK's, but the metal seems too smooth. Still, the metal works for this skin, and that's important. The handle could use some work. If you make a wood handle, you should take away that depression on the handle and just make the whole thing smoothe wood. The front grip looks awesome, the wood's nicely done, but a little dark. The magazine's too dark. I suggest you use a real AK-74M magazine for it like on the 2215 AK-74 skin, since the green waffle-mag just looks horrible. I think it would be better if you made it lighter, though. This texture is very nice, it works well with the colours you used and doesn't feel as "rocky" as others.	Approved 9/10
	Skins > Makarov new retexture It looks nice and detailed, lots of effort is apparent. It still has some errors, though, on realism, which is what it looks like you went for here. The Makarov is never that kind of matte-coloured. Again, as I said before, it kinda looks rocky. A real Makarov is not that dark, and a dark-gray most of the time. The handle needs some lighting and more highlights. It's plastic, after all, and the kind of plastic used on a Makarov is not matte-ish. The frame looks good, but it needs to be gray, not black. The slide needs to be much shinier, the slide on a Makarov, even a modern one, is never matte-black like you have here. It is always gray and polished. Here is a reference, the gun in the picture is a typical Makarov PM police issue with a black finish. They are usually gray, but also exist in black. You see how it is shiny on the slide and handle? Overall, your skin's very nice and I can see alot of effort, but it could be better. Personally, I think the default 2215/Clear Sky Makarov skin has more dimension and realism the way I like.	Approved 8.5/10
	Skins > Walther P99 retexture Very nice, alot of effort, as always. What I don't like is that, again, it looks a little plain. There should be some more highlights or shine, especially since it's a P-99. The metal parts are not that matte-coloured, even on the black one. Again, it kind of looks like a rock. Very detailed and realistic, but it feels like it's missing something.	Approved 8.8/10
	Skins > SVU retexture It's better than the original, but looks a little...plain. I see that it took a lot of effort, but the skin seems like a hunk of matte metal, no offense. Kinda seems "rocklike." I think there should be a little more shine and the metal should be a bit smoother. Either that, or make the front grip a little shinier. Plastic, especially the kind used on Russian guns is not that matte-ish. All in all, I see amazing effort, I just think you should make the metal a little shinier with highlights and make the plastic parts have a noticeable difference between the metal. The skin just seems too "one-coloured."	Approved 8/10
	Skins > Alpha Clear Sky Stalkers I think the Alpha versions of these player models were far more realistic and logical. The final versions are a little too "neat," not enough gear and details. It's wierd that GSC decided to take a step back like that.	Approved 10/10
	Skins > New Inventory Screens. Freedom Freedom! Yay! Thanks alot for this. By the way, PLEASE tell me where you found the Clear Sky suit in your inventory. I've been searching for it for a looooong time. ... Fuck Duty.	Approved 9.5/10
	Skins > LR300 - Replica HK416 v2 Woooooooah, man. You underestimate yourself. This is one amazing skin. And I like that fact that it is generally one color all-over, the HK-416 has a matte-finish anyway. Wow, dude. Great work.	Approved 9/10
	Skins > Pseudodoggles v1.2 Dude, fucking LOL!! This is so hilarious and funny. I was just laughing so hard when reading your description. XD Seriously, lots of effort and originality in here. Guys, lighten up, it's not meant to be realistic, Jeez. Love this skin, man. What's next...bloosucker...helmets or something? :D	Approved 9.8/10

Page of 14 1 2 3 4 ... 12 13 14